Tuesday, November 6, 2007

Game Critique - second set of prez

Game #5
Name of the Game: 3rd cloud

Art
- no distinctive art pieces presented to judge this.
Balance
- balance need to be tweaked, perhaps. A bit complicated in some areas, and lacking materials in others.
Mechanics
- cool game mechanics, but still need to work out some kinks.
Originality
- a lot of similar games already in market.
How well the prototype resembles the game
- For a game like this, it might have been difficult to build a prototype. nicely done.


Game #6
Name of the Game: Food fights

Art
- no strong art yet to judge this.
Balance
- pretty simple, easily balanced.
Model they used
- satisfactory.
Mechanics
- When does the game end?
Originality
- Similar games out in the market. But still looks pretty fun.
How well the prototype resembles the game
- satisfactory.


Game #7
Name of the Game: Drive Thru Tycoon

Art
- cool art work.
Balance
- well balanced. This type of game is already in the market.
Model they used
- nice
Mechanics
- pretty solid mechanics.
Originality
- Many different types of drive-thru games are already in the market.
How well the prototype resembles the game
- Pretty well designed prototype

Game #8
Name of the Game: Circular Strife

Art
- cool art
Balance
- well thought out
Model they used
- Highly ambitious, perhaps too ambitious?
Mechanics
- well thought out game mechanics, seems fun
Originality
- pretty unique
How well the prototype resembles the game
- The prototype was very well done. Smartly designed.

Game #9
Name of the Game: Sick Ninja
-- no presentation

No comments: